• Unvaccinated kids: Schools in Western Washington most at risk for measles

    By: Deedee Sun

    Updated:

    The measles crisis continues to grow in Washington state and around the country.

    As a battle continues in the state Legislature over whether students should be allowed to skip vaccines for personal reasons, KIRO 7 learned there are some schools in our state – including in Snohomish County – with hundreds of unvaccinated students.

    Where are the spots most at risk for a measles outbreak? Reporter Deedee Sun dug into data from the Washington State Department of Health on school vaccination opt-out risks to find out – plus what's being done to address the hot spots.

    Scroll down to continue reading


    More news from KIRO 7


    DOWNLOAD OUR FREE NEWS APP

    About one in every four students at Monroe’s Sky Valley Education Center are not vaccinated against measles, about 212 students at the Snohomish County public school who opted out of the MMR vaccine in the 2017-18 school year.

    And it's not alone.

    “When we look across the state of Washington, we see little pockets of school districts or areas in certain counties where there's higher than expected rates of unimmunized folks. And that's where any of these diseases can take place,” said Dr. Scott Lindquist, the Washington State Department of Health’s epidemiologist for communicable diseases.

    The measles outbreak in Clark County started after an infected international traveler went to a Portland basketball game -- then those infected people went to southern Washington.

    “This outbreak, while it was in this unimmunized community, quickly spread to the public through places like Costco, Ikea, a basketball game, schools,” Lindquist said.

    So far 72 people have gotten sick and most of them are unimmunized kids in Clark County.

    As you might expect, several schools in the Battle Ground School District in Clark County have high rates of vaccine opt outs.

    River HomeLink has nearly a quarter of its kids exempt from the MMR vaccine, or 239 students.

    But data from the DOH shows there are many areas in western Washington that a high percentage of unvaccinated students – and all are hot spots for measles.

    “It can be any place where kids that are unimmunized congregate. So it can be a church, sports groups, schools,” Lindquist said.

    It means if that measles-carrying traveler had come into contact with any of those communities -- the outbreak would've happened here. So which are most at risk?

    KIRO 7 through the DOH data for the last school year of about 2,500 schools, focusing on public schools with more than 200 kids.

    Topping the charts is Skagit Academy in the Mount Vernon school district.

    About 40 percent (or 138) students did not get the MMR vaccine there, making it the public school with the highest percentage of unvaccinated kids in Washington State (among schools with more than 200 students). 

    “It does present a real concern to us. Particularly when we have opt out rates as high as they are at the academy,” said Dr. Carl Bruner, superintendent of the Mount Vernon School District.

    “Our top priority with all of our programs and schools is student health and student safety. And to the extent that students are not adequately immunized present risks both for themselves and their peers when it comes to health and safety – and also to staff to be frank,” Bruner said.

    The Washington State Legislature is considering a bill that would ban personal or philosophical exemptions for the MMR vaccine, and possibly for all vaccines.

    But Mount Vernon's superintendent says given current state law, their options for increasing vaccination rates at Skagit Academy are limited.

    “I'm not sure what else we can do,” Bruner said. “I think that we're doing everything we can do. We are communicating at times a daily basis with not only specific families, but also just the general public about the importance that we believe immunization carries. We’re doing everything I think we know how to do, to convince people to take a second and third look at that,” Bruner said.

    He said usually, the outreach works.

    “Most of the times it's successful. At Skagit Academy it has not been successful for almost 40 percent of our students,” Bruner said.

    Another hot spot is at Edmonds Heights K-12.

    “We were identified as a school of risk for herd immunity,” said Mara Marano-Bianco, program manager for health services for the Edmonds School District.

    The vaccine opt-out rate at Edmonds Heights is also 24 percent (or 135 students).

    “The department of health specifically reached out to this school?” KIRO 7’s Deedee Sun asked the school’s principal, Scott Mauk.

    “That was an interesting meeting,” Mauk said. “When the DOH came and sat down in my office with me, we were like well – let's make a plan. So we just did a pretty serious outreach plan,” he said.

    Marano-Bianco said the outreach did help – a little.

    “Did that really move the needle?” Marano-Bianco said. She hesitated, before saying, “It did. We are in compliance but we still do have a lot of exemption letters here at this school,” she said.

    “Is it part of the school's' goal to continue lowering the number of people who opt out?” Sun asked the school’s principal.

    “I think it's really more of a district thing. We'll do what the district and county need us to do,” Mauk said.

    All three of the public schools – Skagit Academy, Sky Valley Education Center, and Edmonds Heights K-12  – are all alternative schools that combine homeschooling with classroom learning.

    The school districts each couldn't point to why their respective alternative school had such high opt out rates. But parents who chose to skip at least some vaccinations for their kids said they believe the shots come with risks.

    “There are so many pros and cons to both,” said Janet Randall, a Monroe parent.

    “I've chosen to vaccinate somewhat. I think we all hold our breath, making sure everything will go well,” said Maria Hansen, parent at Skagit Academy.

    The CDC says the MMR vaccine is very safe.

    Common side effects can be a sore arm, mild rash, or fever  from the shot -- but any complications, are extremely rare.

    The department of health says the bigger risk is the measles disease, and the vulnerability these schools bring to their communities.

    “These (schools) represent potential areas where another outbreak could occur,” Lindquist said, looking over the list of schools with the highest vaccine opt out rates.

    There is a silver lining – the Clark County measles outbreak that started in January has spurred thousands of families to get vaccinated since.

     

    Data is sourced from the Department of Health's website

    Public schools (200+ students) in Washington with high MMR vaccine opt-out rates (2017-18 data)

    School Reported Enrollment Percent exempt for MMR Number Exempt for MMR School District
    Skagit Academy (Family Learning Center) 349 39.5% 138

    Mount Vernon School District

    Lynden Academy 223 23.8% 53 Lynden School District
    Sky Valley Education Center 896 23.7% 212 Monroe School District
    Edmonds Heights K-12 571 23.6% 135 Edmonds School District
    River Homelink 1019 23.5% 239 Battle Ground School District
    Homeconnection 308 22.4% 69 Oak Harbor School District
    Five Mile Prairie School 490 20.0% 98 Mead School District
    Oly Regional Learning Academy 462 16.2% 75 Olympia School District
    Orla Montessori 213 15.5% 33 Olympia School District
    Cascade K-8 Community School 224 14.3% 32 Shoreline School District
    Spokane Public Montessori 448 13.8% 62 Spokane School District
    Maple Grove School 483 13.5% 65 Battle Ground School District
    Lincoln Elementary 283 12.7% 36 Olympia School District
    Mount Baker Junior High 305 12.5% 38 Mount Baker School District
    Cam Academy 528 12.1% 64

    Battle Ground School District

    Lakeland Elementary School 431 11.8% 51 Federal Way School District
    Daybreak Primary 508 11.0% 56 Battle Ground School District
    Kendall Elementary 420 11.0% 46 Mount Baker School District
    Reardan Elementary School 288 10.8% 31 Rearden-Edwall School District
    Fort Colville Elementary 414 10.6% 44 Colville School District
    Otis Orchards School 430 10.5% 45 East Valley School District (Spokane)
    Mid-Columbia Parent Partnership

    312

    10.3% 32 Kennewick School District
    Summit View Alt High School 365 10.1% 37 Battle Ground School District
    Pleasant Valley Primary 585 10.1% 59

    Battle Ground School District

    Liberty Bell Jr Sr High 288 10.1% 29 Methow Valley School District

     

    Private schools (200+ students) in Washington with high MMR vaccine opt-out rates (2017-18 data):

     

    School Reported Enrollment Percent Exempt for MMR Number Exempt for MMR School District
    Tacoma Christian Academy 275 56.4% 155 Tacoma School District
    Academy Northwest (Marysville campus) 284 25.0% 71 Marysville School District
    Seattle Waldorf School 356 22.5% 80 Seattle Public Schools
    Firm Foundation Christian School 290 20.0% 58 Battle Ground School District
    Providence Classical Christian School 226 18.1% 41 Edmonds School District
    Cedar Tree Classical Christian School 209 17.7% 37 Battle Ground School District
    The River Academy 204 16.2% 33 Wenatchee School District 
    Valley Christian School 284 14.4% 41 Central Valley School District
    Cornerstone Christian School 302 14.2% 43 Evergreen School District
    Christian Faith School 270 14% 37 Federal Way School District
    Mount Vernon Christian School 291 13.4% 39 Mount Vernon School District
    Northwest Christian High School 552 11.1% 61 Mead School District
    Cedar Park Christian School 975 11% 107 Northshore School District
    Auburn Adventist Academy 227 9.3% 21 Auburn School District
    Renton Christian School 433 9.2% 40 Renton School District
    Rogers Adventist School 315 9.2% 29 College Place School District
    Grace Academy  313 8.6% 27 Marysville School District
    Northwest Christian Elementary School and Middle School 358 8.1% 29 Spokane School District
    Bellingham Christian School 202 7.9% 16 Bellingham School District
    Buena Vista SDA School 217 7.8% 17 Auburn School District
    Bryant Montessori School 340 7.4% 25 Tacoma School District
    Archbishop Thomas J. Murphy High School 396 7.1% 28 Spokane School District
    Northshore Christian Academy  870 6.8% 59 Mukilteo School District
    Upper Columbia Academy 227 6.6% 15 Liberty School District
    Meadowglade SDA School 307 6.5% 20 Battleground School District

    Next Up: