WASHINGTON — Does all the recycling you drop into the bin really get recycled?
It’s a question fueled by millions of views on social media, where doubters and skeptics claim recycling is a “scam” and that your carefully sorted bottles, cans and cardboard are likely buried in the same landfill as the stuff from your garbage bin.
To test those “curbside conspiracy theories,” KIRO 7 followed recyclable materials across three counties.
We attached Apple AirTags to 12 recyclable items, including cardboard from typical shipping boxes, aluminum cans, steel cans, and heavy-grade plastic. We dropped them into recycling bins across King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties.
Then we watched the trackers move.
We fully expected at least one might lead us to a landfill.
None did.
All 12 were routed to facilities that process the specific types of recyclables we put into the bins. Some stopped transmitting from recycling sorting facilities. Others traveled much farther.
One cardboard tracker pinged about 130 miles from where we dropped it, at a paper mill in Longview, Washington, that produces new cardboard boxes.
A tracker attached to a steel can wound up about 170 miles south in Vancouver, Washington, after passing through a sorting facility in Woodinville. The can had been crushed into a bale of steel weighing nearly a ton. Its tracker was still pinging days later from a scrap-metal company that ships steel to buyers across the Pacific, where recycled steel can be made into products such as rebar and I-beams used in construction.
Although our sample size was small, the experiment provided a surprisingly positive answer to one question: We found no evidence our clean recyclables were simply collected at the curb and hauled to a landfill.
But public records obtained by KIRO 7 show the recycling story is more complicated after those materials reach a sorting facility.
King County study
King County’s 2022 material recovery facility assessment estimated that approximately 283,000 tons of recycling entered material recovery facilities, or MRFs, during the year.
About 40,800 tons, roughly 14%, ended up as residual material headed for disposal.
What researchers found in that residual material was significant: The county estimated that 40.3% of it was recyclable material.
That works out to roughly 16,400 tons of recyclable material lost from the recycling stream after being processed at a sorting facility.
Among the estimated recyclable material in those residuals were:
- About 3,368 tons of corrugated cardboard and kraft paper
- About 861 tons of PET No. 1 bottles, typically beverage and household-cleaner bottles marked with a No. 1 recycling symbol
- About 671 tons of aluminum cans
- About 433 tons of tin food cans
- About 133 tons of natural HDPE bottles, such as plastic milk jugs
- About 127 tons of colored HDPE, commonly used for laundry detergent and bleach bottles
Those numbers matter because cardboard, PET plastic, aluminum and steel or tin were among the same types of material KIRO 7 tracked.
The findings do not mean workers or recycling companies simply threw away all 16,400 tons. Waste Management and Republic Services told KIRO 7 that recyclables can become unrecoverable for many reasons, including contamination and limitations in the sorting process.
But the study demonstrates an important distinction: Getting a recyclable item to the proper recycling facility does not guarantee it will be recycled.
So, what happens after recycling gets to the sorting facility?
Several of KIRO 7’s trackers led to the Cascade Recycling Center in Woodinville, operated by Waste Management.
We went inside to see what happened after the recycling arrived.
Hundreds of tons of material from communities in King, Snohomish and Skagit counties move through the facility each day. Workers still remove plastic bags and other unwanted material, but much of the sorting is performed mechanically.
Three years ago, Waste Management rebuilt the 82,000-square-foot plant with sophisticated automated sorting technology.
Recyclables race along conveyors through screens and scanning equipment that separate material by size and type. High-speed optical sorters identify and separate different materials. Recovered cardboard, aluminum, plastics and steel are ultimately compressed into large, heavy bales for shipment to buyers.
Waste Management’s Grace Fletcher described what happens after people put accepted materials into their recycling bins:
“After you put the right stuff in the right bin, it goes for a hell of a ride.”
The technology is sophisticated, but it is not perfect.
Waste Management data provided to King County for August 2026 offers a more recent snapshot. Records show the facility processed approximately 4,922 tons of material, with about 714 tons classified as residue, or roughly 14.5%, headed for disposal.
That percentage is close to the approximately 14% residual rate estimated in King County’s 2022 MRF study.
However, the newer data does not establish that all 714 tons was recyclable material. It also does not mean otherwise recyclable material was put into the wrong bin. Residue can include contamination and material that cannot be recovered through the sorting process.
A landfill problem is looming
The issue extends beyond recyclables lost during sorting.
King County’s 2022 waste characterization study estimated that about 172,600 tons of recyclable material were found in the county’s waste stream. That’s about 20% of all disposed material.
That included an estimated:
- 36,794 tons of cardboard and kraft paper
- 6,680 tons of PET No. 1 bottles
- 3,346 tons of aluminum cans
- 2,899 tons of tin food cans
Those numbers tell a different story from the MRF data. They reflect recyclable material people threw into the garbage stream, not material placed in recycling bins and later lost during sorting.
King County has also estimated that a far larger share of material being disposed could potentially be recycled, composted or otherwise diverted rather than buried.
The stakes are visible at Cedar Hills Regional Landfill near Maple Valley, King County’s only remaining active landfill, which King County estimates will be at capacity and will need to close in about 12 years.
KIRO 7 illustrated the amount of potentially divertible material entering the landfill by comparing its weight with the weight of 60 Space Needles.
What our 12 trackers showed us
Our experiment was obviously much smaller than King County’s waste stream study. But it did allow us to test a common claim: that clean curbside recycling is simply picked up and routed to a landfill.
That did not happen to any of the 12 items we tracked.
Our clean, accepted recyclables were routed to three recycling-processing facilities in Tacoma, Woodinville and Seattle’s Sodo neighborhood. When the trackers continued transmitting, we were able to follow some material farther downstream.
For Grace Fletcher, the results reinforce a basic message she gives visitors to the Woodinville sorting facility.
If people put the right recyclable material in the right bin, “It goes to the right place and it gets recycled,” Fletcher told KIRO 7. “So, I guess that’s the main takeaway here.”
So why didn’t KIRO 7 track glass?
Glass is handled differently depending on the local recycling system, and it isn’t accepted in much of Pierce County’s curbside recycling program.
To make the experiment more comparable across all three counties, KIRO 7 focused on materials accepted in King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties.
A note about our experiment: Don’t try this at home
Waste Management and Republic Services told KIRO 7 after the experiment that AirTags should never be placed in recycling bins because their batteries can pose a fire risk during processing. The companies advise customers to keep batteries and battery-powered devices out of the recycling stream.
KIRO 7 does not recommend attempting a similar tracking experiment.
Watch KIRO 7 News at 5:30 p.m. on Wednesday for the full story.
©2026 Cox Media Group




