Seattle schools raise concerns over new girls’ sports law; status of 1,400 athletes in limbo

This browser does not support the video element.

SEATTLE — With just two weeks before Washington’s new girls’ sports law takes effect, Seattle Public Schools is backing an effort to temporarily block the measure, warning it lacks enough clarity to implement the new requirements mid-winter sports season.

In a filing this week, the district said approximately 1,400 students on its girls’ winter sports rosters already have valid physicals on file that do not include the sex verification required under Initiative 638.

The initiative, approved by Washington voters earlier this month, is set to take effect Dec. 3. It prevents students it defines as “biologically male” from participating in female-designated interscholastic sports and establishes sex-verification requirements for students seeking to participate in those sports.

The ACLU of Washington has sued to overturn the law and is seeking a preliminary injunction that would prevent it from taking effect while the legal challenge proceeds.

“How do the districts implement this law?” ACLU of Washington staff attorney Adrien Leavitt told KIRO 7. “How do they implement this in the middle of the school year, in the middle of sports seasons?”

Seattle Public Schools is not a plaintiff in the lawsuit. Instead, the district filed a motion supporting the plaintiffs’ request for a preliminary injunction.

In the filing, SPS argues it “cannot faithfully implement” the initiative by Dec. 3 without additional guidance because key terms are undefined and districts face unanswered questions about how the law immediately applies to students who are already participating in sports.

Seattle Public Schools said approximately 2,000 students are currently on girls’ winter sports rosters. About 1,400 of them have physicals that are valid and will not expire within the next 90 days, but those existing forms do not include the new sex verification.

The district argues that creates an immediate question when the law takes effect: Can those students continue competing with the physicals they already have, or must they obtain additional documentation first?

If the students cannot continue competing, SPS told the court it may have to bench them until they obtain the required statement, potentially leaving some teams without enough eligible athletes to compete. The district argues that could cost students opportunities this season and, in some cases, affect future athletic or academic opportunities.

If students can continue playing temporarily, however, the district argues it would effectively have to create a grace period not included in the initiative.

The Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA)says girls who don’t return the form by Dec. 3 would be allowed to practice, but not compete in winter sports, including girls’ wrestling, flag football, bowling, gymnastics, and competitive cheer.

SPS also said it does not know how quickly health care providers could complete new forms, particularly for students who do not have a regular provider.

Let’s Go Washington, which led the campaign supporting Initiative 638, is optimistic families will have enough time to complete the new forms because student athletes and their families already routinely deal with eligibility requirements.

“Eligibility is a requirement; it’s something that’s been happening for school sports for a very long time,” Let’s Go Washington Executive Director Darren Littell told KIRO 7.

Asked directly whether the necessary work could be completed before Dec. 3, Littell said he believed it could.

“I do think that it can get done in two weeks,” Littell said.

Littell also characterized the process for families as straightforward.

“All you need to do is share it with your doctor,” he said. “They’ve already got all the information they need.”

The district says it would also have to determine how to collect the new documentation and who can access it. SPS argues storing the new forms and potentially changing access permissions could require additional time and resources.

The district is also raising a separate question it says cannot be solved simply by collecting new forms: how Initiative 638 should operate alongside existing Washington nondiscrimination laws.

The district argues those existing provisions prohibit discrimination based on gender identity or gender expression.

“How do the schools maintain their obligations, their anti-discrimination obligations under state law when implementing, when also tasked to implement this law?” Leavitt said.

SPS argues that could leave district employees with seemingly competing directives: enforce the new athletic eligibility requirements while also complying with existing protections for transgender students.

The district also raised concerns about potential liability if it implements the initiative and a court later determines some or all of the law is unconstitutional.

Let’s Go Washington disputes the broader constitutional challenge.

“Whether or not this is constitutional is really the question,” Littell said. “And the clear answer is yes, this is a constitutional law and it is updating the existing requirements.”

That question has not yet been decided by the court.

The ACLU lawsuit asks the court to declare the initiative unconstitutional under Washington state law. In the meantime, plaintiffs are seeking a preliminary injunction to prevent the measure from taking effect while the case proceeds.

Seattle Public Schools argues a temporary pause would allow existing athletic eligibility rules to remain in place while the court considers the challenge and would prevent schools from having to implement new requirements that could later be invalidated.

A judge is scheduled to consider the request for a preliminary injunction on Dec. 3 — the same day Initiative 638 is set to take effect.

The ACLU told KIRO 7 it moved as quickly as it could to challenge the measure.

Under the initiative’s timeline, the new law takes effect 30 days after it was approved by voters.