New legislation would allow data centers on public land

This browser does not support the video element.

SEATTLE, Wash. — A bill moving quickly through U.S. Congress would bring permitting reform for energy and data center projects, while also rescinding input from tribal nations and walking back environmental protections.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), sponsored by four bipartisan senators, was introduced on Sept. 30, but was never heard or read in committee hearings where stakeholders typically give feedback.

Instead, it went straight to the Senate floor for a procedural vote Tuesday. Washington Senator Maria Cantwell said she didn’t get the bill until Sunday night.

“This process has been one in which we didn’t have hearings, didn’t have a markup, [and] basically came to the Senate floor without much notice and debate,” Cantwell said. “Right at the aftermath of an election, and, so, I just feel like it hasn’t gotten the attention that it deserves.”

The bill would reform the permitting process for projects related to the electricity grid to accommodate an increasing load of electricity.

The goal is to speed up approval for energy projects to develop renewable energies like solar and wind, as well as traditional oil, gas, and coal projects. It does this by limiting the scope of several review processes designed to protect environments, endangered species, and sensitive historical sites.

“While Washington Wild supports infrastructure for energy transmission and future solutions, bedrock environmental laws and tribal consultation should not be held hostage to do so.” Washington Wild executive director Tom Uniack said.

BAAJA would prioritize ensuring the certainty of a project moving forward, rather than revisit legal, analytical, or clarity errors in the original permit, making them difficult for future administrations to reverse course.

It would limit the Endangered Species Act (ESA) by changing the definition of “best available science” that ensured agencies and developers must prioritize protection of endangered species.

It also requires states to take on the review project to ensure federal projects meet ESA standards, something the organization Earth Justice says few states, if any, have the resources to do.

“This is really concerning, because it is legislation and there’s a finality to that, if they make the wrong choice,” Uniack said.

BAAJA also changes the National Environmental Review Act processes by altering the best available science requirement and exempting many projects from the review completely.

It changes the Clean Water Act by doubling the length of water pollution permits, limiting state and tribes’ ability to protect waters in its jurisdiction, and makes it easier for developers to fill in wetlands -- regardless of flooding or wildlife concerns.

“I’m for building transmission, but last I checked, that was not the problems with transmission. It wasn’t because, oh my god, we had to run over the Clean Water Act, because we couldn’t get transmission,” Cantwell said.

The bill aims to lower electricity costs by requiring data centers to pay for electricity and projects that require increasing electrical capacity, and, with shorter review periods, lowering the cost of projects.

Sovereign Indigenous Tribes are speaking out, because both the National Environmental Policy Act process and the National Historic Preservation Acts have ensured a seat at the table for feedback and consultation on projects that directly or indirectly impact tribal nations.

“My people have already paid far too much for this country’s energy development,” Yakama Nation tribal councilmember John Washines said. “We should not be asked to sacrifice our salmon and our treaty rights yet again.”