How online and in-store prices differ at top retailers

SEATTLE — When you walk into a store, you might expect to pay the same price for an item that the retailer is advertising online.

But that is not always the case.

KIRO 7 compared prices and promotions for 13 items across five retailers: Target, Walgreens, Best Buy, QFC, and Lowe’s. We found examples where online and in-store discounts matched, but we also found items that appeared cheaper online and promotions reserved specifically for customers shopping online, through an app, or for pickup or delivery.

The takeaway: It can pay to check your phone before you check out.

Target

At Target, KIRO 7 checked two electronics products.

Beats Solo 4 headphones appeared online for $149, while the shelf initially showed $199. However, when we asked a Target employee about the difference, she told us the item was simply missing its sale tag and said the $149 sale price should appear when the headphones were scanned.

We found a different result with an Amazon Echo. The item was marked $199 in the store but was listed for $149 online, a $50 difference.

Target referred KIRO 7 to its Price Match Guarantee policy when we asked about differences between online and in-store pricing.

“We match Target.com prices on in-store purchases and in-store prices for Target.com purchases,” that policy says. “In-store price matches from other Target stores are excluded.”

That means shoppers who spot a lower Target price online should check with an employee to match it in store.

Walgreens

At Walgreens, we purchased three everyday products in the store: ChapStick, candy, and Tylenol. We then loaded the same products into an online pickup order to see how the total compared.

The pickup order was about $12 cheaper.

Part of the difference came from the Tylenol, which was priced lower online than in the store.

Savings also came from a broader digital promotion available online that offered a discount on the total order once reaching a certain amount.

Walgreens told KIRO 7 that its policy is to match a lower Walgreens retail price found on Walgreens.com or in the Walgreens app.

“Customers who find a lower Walgreens retail price online are encouraged to bring it to the attention of a store team member,” the Walgreens Communications Team said.

But the company draws a distinction between a lower retail price and a digital promotion.

“Digital promotions and promotional offers may be exclusive to Walgreens.com or the Walgreens app and do not apply to in-store purchases when identified as online-only,” Walgreens said.

The company said the terms associated with those offers specify where they are available.

Walgreens also acknowledged that customers may not necessarily be looking at its app while they walk through the store.

“We recognize that not all customers shop with our app in hand, and we continue to evaluate how to make it easier for customers to know when additional savings are available,” the company said.

Best Buy

Our Best Buy check was more straightforward.

We compared two products and found the discounts offered in the store matched what we found online.

However, that does not mean shoppers should assume the prices will always be identical.

“The Deal of the Day offers can be available online only or available online and in stores,” Best Buy’s website claims.

QFC

At QFC, the paper coupons we checked in the store matched the discounts we found through the company’s app.

But we also found deals specifically advertised for pickup and delivery. On one product, the pickup or delivery promotion offered an additional $2 in savings compared with shopping for the product in the store.

QFC told KIRO 7 that it offers promotions across its in-store, pickup, and delivery options, but some offers are available only through particular ways of shopping.

“Some offers are available only through a particular shopping method, and any applicable eligibility requirements or redemption terms are disclosed with the offer,” a QFC spokesperson said.

The company also pointed out that customers do not necessarily need the app to access every digital deal.

QFC said it provides in-store flyers for its Weekly Digital Deals that can be scanned at checkout, and employees can help shoppers access those offers.

Lowe’s

At Lowe’s, we again found mixed results.

The price of a toilet we checked matched online and in the store.

But when we compared the price of a garbage disposal, the app showed it for $37 less than the price we found in the store.

A Lowe’s employee told KIRO 7 the store typically tries to price-match. KIRO 7 also contacted Lowe’s corporate with questions about its online and in-store pricing but did not receive a response.

So, is shopping online actually cheaper?

Not necessarily.

Herb Weisbaum, a contributing editor at Checkbook.org, said shoppers should not assume either method will always produce the lowest price.

“Online shopping may be cheaper; there’s no guarantee,” Weisbaum said. “There may be a lower price in the store.”

He recommends comparing prices not just between a retailer’s website and its physical store, but among competing retailers.

“The only way to know is to shop around,” Weisbaum said. “Not only between online and store, but between various retailers, because prices really do vary from store to store.”

For major purchases, Weisbaum said the payoff can be significant. He said he recently saved $1,000 while shopping online for a heater for his hot tub.

“You could save hundreds, maybe thousands of dollars a year,” he said.

Of course, comparison shopping takes time.

Seattle shopper Melissa Strauch said she knows she could check prices online while shopping, but usually does not.

“I’m busy, and I don’t have time to go online and check and keep track of all that,” Strauch said.

And some shoppers told KIRO 7 they expected a retailer’s prices to be consistent regardless of where they make the purchase.

“Of course I expect it to be the same online,” Seattle shopper Jonathan Addy said. “If I have to go to the store and the price is completely different, then of course I’m going to be a little disappointed.”

What shoppers can do

Our checks represent a snapshot of the prices and promotions available when KIRO 7 visited the five retailers. Prices and promotions can change, and our comparison was not designed to determine whether online or in-store shopping is cheaper overall.

But it did show why checking both can matter.

Before paying in a store:

  • Search the retailer’s website or app for the same product.
  • If you find a lower price, ask whether the store will match its own online price.
  • Check the terms of digital promotions. A retailer may match a lower retail price but exclude an online-only coupon or promotion.
  • Pay attention to whether a discount requires pickup, delivery, a loyalty account, or another specific way of shopping.
  • For larger purchases, compare prices among multiple retailers, not just the online and in-store prices at one company.

And if you are shopping online, browser extensions that search for coupon codes, along with retailer email and text alerts, can provide additional opportunities to save.

The few seconds it takes to check could make a difference at checkout.

Watch KIRO 7 News at 5:30 p.m. on Thursday for the full story.