U.S. Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash., is calling on Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to take immediate action to stop advanced American artificial intelligence technology from reaching companies tied to China, arguing that the Department of Commerce has failed to protect U.S. national security and the nation’s competitive edge in AI.
In a letter sent ahead of Lutnick’s planned trip to China for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, Cantwell, the ranking member of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, accused the department of weakening export controls and allowing Chinese-linked companies access to advanced American AI chips.
“The Department of Commerce is charged with export controls to protect America’s technological edge and to keep sensitive technology out of the hands of our adversaries,” Cantwell wrote. “Despite clear authority from Congress, the Department of Commerce has allowed advanced AI chips to flow through companies with ties to the People’s Republic of China.”
Cantwell’s four main concerns
Cantwell’s letter outlines four areas where she says the department has failed to enforce export control laws meant to prevent foreign adversaries from using sensitive technology.
Among her concerns is what she describes as a loophole allowing Chinese companies to use overseas data centers equipped with advanced Nvidia chips to train AI models. Cantwell cited reports that companies including Alibaba and ByteDance have accessed high-powered American technology outside China despite U.S. restrictions.
She also criticized the department for failing to act against Megaspeed, a company she said national security officials repeatedly flagged. According to the letter, officials from the Treasury, State, and Defense departments urged Commerce to impose restrictions on the company beginning in 2025, but took no action.
Cantwell further alleged that the Commerce Department suspended an investigation into the possible diversion of advanced AI chips to China after contact from Nvidia’s general counsel. She said the decision allowed Megaspeed to keep acquiring sensitive technology while a separate criminal investigation continued.
The Washington senator also objected to the department’s suspension of a Bureau of Industry and Security rule that extended export restrictions to subsidiaries owned by blacklisted companies. She argued the move reopened a loophole that could allow restricted Chinese firms to obtain American technology through affiliated entities.
“The Department of Commerce has resisted efforts to restrict companies flagged as national security threats, weakened safeguards, and left open pathways for the PRCto train advanced AI models using sensitive American technology,” Cantwell stated. “These failures to carry out the law help give away America’s technology advantage in AI.”
Additional questions
The letter additionally raises questions about potential conflicts of interest involving Lutnick and his family’s financial ties to Nvidia stock through Cantor Fitzgerald. Cantwell also criticized a 25% fee imposed on certain Nvidia chip exports to China, saying it creates a financial incentive to approve exports of technology that could benefit foreign competitors.
“America cannot maintain its leadership in AI if the agency responsible for protecting that advantage fails to enforce its own controls,” Cantwell wrote. “The Administration must account for its failure to enforce these protections and take immediate action to prevent America’s most sensitive technology from strengthening our adversaries.”
The Commerce Department has not publicly responded to the allegations outlined in Cantwell’s letter.
The letter was dated Nov. 15 and released publicly on Monday.
Nvidia fallout
The letter from Cantwell follows just days after Nvidia’s CEO Jensen Huang faced scrutiny after his extramarital affair with an alleged Chinese spy sparked U.S. national security concerns, according to the Associated Press.
Huang resigned on Nov. 12 amid the fallout, which has created a ripple effect across the global technology industry, as Huang was known as a worldwide leader in AI growth.
Experts are reportedly watching closely for the effects of Huang’s resignation and what it may mean for the stock market, as well as for other growing AI companies with public debuts pending.
Read more of Regan Gallo-Fenz’s stories here. Submit news tips here.